Big Cats (Stories)
By Holiday Reinhorn
Reviewed by David Barringer
A gifted, empathetic writer with a thing for epiphany over resolution,
Reinhorn in her debut story collection, Big Cats rolls as steadily with young characters on the edge as she does with older
ones doing their damnedest not to return to the edge. Each story slips into
you from the get-go. Drama depends on folks with hurt, history and heartache.
It's not about the earthquake at the bank but the employee's emotional
paralysis; not about beasts roaming free at the zoo but the prickly egos of two girls
chafing to mature in the absence of role models; not about the fragile vanity
of a spiteful matriarch revealing family secrets but the act of charity those
revelations inspire in her daughter.
Reinhorn's characters arrive already chastened by life. Burdened by grief,
addiction, shame, or fear, they yearn for adulthood, sobriety, and love,
transitions they don't know how to accomplish. If this is typical short-story fare
for young American authors taking suburbia as their subject, Reinhorn writes
with lyrical authority about her characters, and that's what counts. Despite
comparisons to Raymond Carver and Denis Johnson, Reinhorn is not a rule-breaker
but, instead, uses short-story convention to get bounce from the emotional ride
of her characters. She's better compared to Charles Baxter and Lorrie Moore.
In the title story, a pair of fourteen-year-old "blood sisters" pair off for
blood sport. Employed for a second summer at the Washington Park Zoo, the
girls resume their best-friend relationship, but with Polly's declaration of
sexual liberation ("'Last summer was for wishing,' Polly says. 'This summer is for
fucking'"), their friendship slips ever so gently into cruel competition. Last
summer they might have sunned topless, but this summer they're critically
assessing themselves and their bodies. Brenda, the narrator, admires Polly's
"nice wide hips" compared to her own, which are "narrow, like a giraffe's," but
rates herself positively breast-wise compared to Polly's "bare-boy flatness on
top." Polly catches Brenda staring, rages with self-consciousness, and, as
quick as you can say "breast envy," retaliates by accusing Brenda of being a
lesbian and by calling her mother names. All the secrets they shared as friends are
now weapons they wield as rivals. With poetic precision, the story tracks the
way two insecure young girls boast, bluff, tease, accuse and attack each
other as they try to make sense of sexuality.
Give credit to Reinhorn for stories as well crafted as "Big Cats," but don't
blame her for the book's cover or quotes. Despite the cover's literal leopard,
her title story features lions. Flattery thunders from all skies: Marilynne
Robinson, Barry Hannah, Dan Chaon, ZZ Packer, Siegfried & Roy (someone in
marketing should be returned to the cage). Gore Vidal all but compares her to Mark
Twain, for chrissakes. Because the publisher dressed her book in fake fur and
pearls and dropped her off at the public pool, readers can't be faulted for
expecting, when the fur drops, a Shakespearean supermodel with thong and
thesaurus. Reinhorn, gratefully, speaks the language of boots and blue jeans,
estrangement and mercy.
|